The Influence of Panel Composition and Matter on Stakeholder Views: Producing Hypotheses from On-line Maternal and Baby Well being Modified-Delphi Panels
Multistakeholder engagement is essential for conducting well being providers analysis. Delphi-based methodologies combining iterative rounds of questions with suggestions on and dialogue of group outcomes are a well-documented method to multistakeholder engagement. This research develops hypotheses concerning the affect of panel composition and subject on the propensity and meaningfulness of response adjustments in multistakeholder modified-Delphi panels.
We carried out three on-line modified-Delphi (OMD) multistakeholder panels utilizing the identical protocol. We assigned 60 maternal and youngster well being professionals to a homogeneous (professionals solely) panel, 60 pregnant or postpartum ladies (sufferers) to a homogeneous panel, and 30 professionals and 30 sufferers to a blended panel. In Spherical 1, contributors rated the seriousness of 11 maternal and youngster well being outcomes utilizing a 0–100 scale and defined their scores. In Spherical 2, contributors noticed their very own and their panel’s Spherical 1 outcomes and mentioned them utilizing asynchronous, nameless dialogue boards moderated by the research investigators. In Spherical 3, contributors revised their authentic scores. Our end result measures included binary indicators of response adjustments to scores of the low, medium and excessive severity maternal and youngster well being outcomes and their meaningfulness, measured by a change of 10 or extra factors.
Members modified 818 of 1491 (55%) of responses; the vast majority of response adjustments have been significant. Patterns of response adjustments have been totally different for sufferers and professionals and for various ranges of end result seriousness. Utilizing research outcomes and the literature, we developed three hypotheses. First, OMD contributors, no matter their stakeholder group, usually tend to change their responses on preference-sensitive subjects the place there’s a vary of viable options or views. Second, sufferers usually tend to change their responses and to take action meaningfully in blended panels, whereas professionals are extra doubtless to take action in homogeneous panels. Third, the affiliation between panel composition and response change varies in response to the subject (e.g., the extent of end result seriousness).
Outcomes of our work not solely helped generate empirically derived hypotheses to be examined in future analysis but additionally provide sensible suggestions for designing multistakeholder OMD panels.
This report is a part of the RAND Company Exterior publication collection. Many RAND research are revealed in peer-reviewed scholarly journals, as chapters in business books, or as paperwork revealed by different organizations.
The RAND Company is a nonprofit establishment that helps enhance coverage and decisionmaking by way of analysis and evaluation. RAND’s publications don’t essentially replicate the opinions of its analysis shoppers and sponsors.